Stephanie has got into the swing of her A-Level studies at College and we have had the opportunity for some interesting comparisons.
We have always had high expectations for our girls and as such they have high expectations of themselves. Our view is that, if you are going to do something, do it to the best of your ability and achieve the best you can.
This view is not shared by the College. Within the first couple of weeks the Chemistry teacher had told all the students they were going to fail. All the others are Cs or below for everyone.
When Stephanie tried to put her own grade expectations into the computer system, it would not let her do it, so the Biology teacher entered it as a C – this was supposed to be Stephanie’s expectations of herself!
Stephanie already has a plan of where she is going and knows what she needs to achieve in order to get there. Her expectations of herself are considerably higher than Cs and Fails! She is a very self-motivated young lady and is putting in a considerable amount of effort at home.
It seems that this idea of teaching, so that students just scrape a pass is quite common. When I went to the CIE IGCSE English Literature day a few weeks ago, the presented explained where the grade boundaries fall and the likely differences where a student would get an A or A* or where it would be a C, D or lower.
For most of the teachers all they were interested in was the lower end boundary between a D and a C. In other words what was the minimum that needed to be done to pass?
My eyes were at the other end of the scale for Jacqueline!
From the personal growth and self help material that I have read over the years, one of the most important factors seems to be EXPECTATIONS. In a learning environment these are expectations that the teachers and parents have of the students and the expectations that the students have of themselves.
If the expectations are low, then the quality of the teaching is unfortunately going to reflect that. I would have thought that if a teacher is really passionate about their subject, that they would want to teach to the highest level that they could and help their students to get the best possible grades. Maybe that is the case, but the system of teaching to lowest expectations does not really allow for that.
Having said that, Stephanie’s anthropology teacher is teaching to the highest expectations and highest level she can. She is partly helped by the fact that this is a completely new subject at A-Level. It has previously only been taught at degree level. As such there is no defined path, no set expectations and there is not even a course book. This year’s intake of students (and there are not very many in the whole country) are the guinea pigs and no-one really knows whart is likely to be set or how harshly or leniently the papers will be marked.
There is always the counter argument that, if you expect too much of people and they don’t match up to those expectations, then there is the possibility that they fail and might feel so bad about themselves that they never try again.
Shoot for the Moon! OK, you might not hit it, however you might get stars instead, but that is considerably further forward that staying on the ground and being afraid to try.
Just a word of warning to any home educators that are considering College for their children. It appears that an ICT qualification is now a “government requirement” in order to study A-Levels.
Half way through the first term, we have now been told that, on top of 5 A-Levels, Stephanie now has to take an hour a week to take a level 2 (GCSE) ICT qualification. This is not based on any assessment of her ICT skills. It is based solely on the fact that she does not have “the piece of paper.”
There was no mention of this anywhere on the College website and no mention of it in her Offer. Had they been kind enough to tell us that it was a requirement, then we could have arranged to take the IGCSE exam, either in the Summer or now in the November session.
Ho, hum! The joys of dealing with the State Education system!
Amanda Goldston
Tags: A-Levels, home education // Comments Off